|
Post by teddyandtimmysdad on Feb 27, 2013 1:02:29 GMT 8
I have been watching my boys play youth football now for 10 years. One of the most disturbing elements in youth football is the lack of on-field discipline commanded by the referees. Within the last 12 months, we had a boy on our team hospitalized with a lacerated liver due to a foul from a particular individual already known throughout the parents of RIFA teams, for his dirty tactics. There has been an incident reported by parents of another RIFA team that an ENTIRE TEAM PLUS THE COACH has been issued a red card. The second incident was not confirmed by me, but if true is really regrettable. These incidents are examples of thuggery in football already arising at an early age. Unfortunately, the lax approach of officials in punishing these fouls appropriately has caused an escalation. Where will it all lead? Consider the recent, astounding story from Hong Kong of an U12 youth kicking another boy in the head. The video of this incident is graphic and amazing, and has created an uproar in the internet (see my blog www.pff-g.com for more details and a link to the video). Ultimately, these incidents are a result of poor officiating. Yellow cards should be issued more often, and referees should NOT be afraid to do so to ensure the play is fair and sportsmanlike without undue physical danger to the boys.
|
|
|
Post by narko on Feb 27, 2013 11:57:20 GMT 8
Totally agree on this one.
In addition to refereeing, I think football authorities should sit down together and strictly lay down general guidelines on how much physicality will be tolerated at levels U14 and below, not to mention how to deal with downright dirty or violent conduct by individual players.
Shouldn't skills development be a priority? Physical play can come into the picture when the bodies of the players are more able to handle it. Is it worth the risk causing injury to a promising 10 or 12 year old player because winning by all means is more important than nurturing these kids to become better players as they get older?
Come to think of it, even the refereeing at the UFL is just as bad. There's all sorts of physical shenanigans going on which the referees fail to address on a CONSISTENT basis, leading them to lose control of the match and the players.
|
|
|
Post by teddyandtimmysdad on Mar 2, 2013 0:36:42 GMT 8
Failure to discipline = loss of control. It is just that simple. I was really happy to see an U18 (U19?  ) "friendly" match today between Ridely School, and the Global Azkals Academy youth team. It was an informal match between the two sides, and the match was generally fast and smooth flowing. However, there was one bad behaved thug on the Ridely defense who was continually fouling the Azkal players. Finally, towards the end of the first half, as one of the azkal players was passing him by, and the defenseman thumped him on the chest with his fist so hard I could hear the slam from thirty yards away. Needless to say, the player was left on the ground clutching his chest in pain. This was no joke and no play acting on the part of the guy on the ground, as the sound of the impact was truly astonishing. To the credit of the ref, he immediately sent the offending defenseman off the field/ Ridely should be embarresed not only by this player's thuggery, but also by his unsportsmanlike behaviour, yelling "faggot" and other atrocities as he left the field. This kid was a real embarressment for Ridely, and they should really take immediate action to get this kid in line or send him off the team. There is no place for this nonsense in football, and all credit to the ref for getting him off the field before frustrations and tempers erupt into much worse. Narco, I agree with you 100pct. And, after having been to a lot of UFL matches with my boys, I have to say I am very reluctant to bring my boys again because I think in many cases the players are setting a poor example for our youth. The UFL needs to get this right - and fast - as I feel it is not good for the growth and accetance of the league. I am at the point of not going at all anymore because I am just too concerned about the negative impact on my boys.
|
|
|
Post by teddyandtimmysdad on Jul 14, 2013 1:36:10 GMT 8
Update = The UFL has done a much better job getting their games under control. The family and I have had a lot of fun going to the matches last season, so I think they are on the right track at the UFL!
|
|